Skip to main content
UCAIug
Login | Join | Help (new window)


UCAIug > Meetings > CIGRE 2014 > Discussion Board > What would you like to seedemonstrate on the UCA booth > What would you like to see or demonstrate on the UCA booth?  

Discussion Board: What would you like to see or demonstrate on the UCA booth?

Body

Hello,

By showing PTP at UCA booth at CIGRE 2014 we would be sending a wrong message to the market. The reality is that still some modifications to the standard need to be made in order to ensure interoperability in case of PTP over PRP and HSR. This will be solved in the new Amendement to IEC 62439 that will clearly define the operation of doubly attached clocks. Implementations and prototypes exist today, but UCA should promote standards based solutions.

Therefore I vote for showing PRP and/or HSR but NOT for showing PTP.

Regards
Maciej



From: marijn.flohil
Posted: Thursday, May 08, 2014 3:11 AM
Subject: What would you like to see or demonstrate on the UCA booth?

Currently, participants have indicated that they are interest in two main topics:

1. Engineering enhancements based on the results from the Interoperability demonstration in Munich.
2. PRP/HSR and PTP.

Which of these topics would you like to see on the UCA booth and what would you like to see or demonstrate in the UCA booth? (E.g. I would like to demonstrate engineering enhancements in my SCL configuration tool, my SCL tool now uses parameters X and Y to determine the correct value for setting Z to prevent issue N that was identified during the interoperability demonstration in Munich.) 
Attachments
Content Type: Message
Created at 5/9/2014 5:18 AM  by maciej.goraj 
Last modified at 5/9/2014 5:18 AM  by maciej.goraj